Factorial significance on tractor stability under variation of terrain roughness employing the Taguchi method

Zhen Li, Zhongxiang Zhu, Jiahao Qin, Enrong Mao, Muneshi Mitsuoka, Eiji Inoue, Soyoung Shin

Abstract


Tractor rollover accidents remain an issue with the development of agricultural mechanization. Adopting the scale-model-based experimental approach, this study investigated the three most influential geometric factors of tractor in various agricultural ground conditions with improved configuration of force sensing system. The initiation of tractor rollover, associated with the tire-ground contact status, was investigated for various front tire types, ballast weights, and rear track widths. Employing the Taguchi method, the ground reaction forces applied to the tractor’s uphill wheels were measured and evaluated using stability indicators. By taking this approach, the effects and statistical significance of the three factors and their interactions were examined under various agricultural ground conditions. Results showed that the ballast weight significantly affected the ground contact status of the uphill front tire. The significance of the front tire type gradually increased as the road roughness increased, but dramatically decreased for an extremely rough road surface. Furthermore, none of the factors or interactions, except the factor of the rear track width for relatively rough roads, was statistically significant. The study revealed that not all commonly discussed factors consistently affect tractor stability. The results of the present study are thus expected to provide a reference explaining how to explore the necessity and feasibility of parameter adjustment before reconfiguring a tractor for higher stability.
Keywords: tractor rollover, scale model, agricultural fields, Taguchi method, factorial significance
DOI: 10.25165/j.ijabe.20181105.3713

Citation: Li Z, Zhu Z X, Qin J H, Mao E R, Mitsuoka M, Inoue E, et al. Factorial significance on tractor stability under variation of terrain roughness employing the Taguchi method. Int J Agric & Biol Eng, 2018; 11(5): 88–94.

Keywords


tractor rollover, scale model, agricultural fields, Taguchi method, factorial significance

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abubakar M S, Ahmad D, Akande F B. A review of farm tractor overturning accidents and safety. Pertanika Journal of Science and Technology, 2010; 18(2): 377–385.

Abu-Hamdeh N H, Al-Jalil H F. Computer simulation of stability and control of tractor-trailed implement combinations under different operating conditions. Bragantia, 2004; 63(1): 149–162.

Ahmed O B, Goupillon J F. Predicting the ride vibration of an agricultural tractor. Journal of Terramechanics, 1997; 34(1): 1–11.

Ahokas J, Kosonen S. Dynamic behaviour of a tractor–trailer combination during braking. Biosystems Engineering, 2003; 85(1): 29–39.

Baker V, Guzzomi A L. A model and comparison of 4-wheel-drive fixed-chassis tractor rollover during Phase I. Biosystems Engineering, 2013; 116(2): 179–189.

Chisholm C J. A mathematical model of tractor overturning and impact behaviour. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1979; 24(4): 375–394.

Chisholm C J. Analysis of rigid-body motion from cine film measurements. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1979; 24(4): 441–446.

Chisholm C J. Experimental validation of a tractor overturning simulation. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1979; 24(4): 395–415.

Davis D C, Rehkugler G E. Agricultural wheel-tractor overturns. Part I: Mathematical model. Transactions of the ASAE, 1974; 17(3): 477–483.

Davis D C, Rehkugler G E. Agricultural wheel-tractor overturns. Part II: Mathematical model verification by scale-model study. Transactions of the ASAE, 1974; 17(3): 484–488, 492.

Zeng D, Zhu Y, Zhou Y. A mathematical model for sideways overturning performance of tractor and trailer combinations. Journal of Terramechanics, 1989; 26(3–4): 193–200.

Rehkugler G E, Kumar V, Davis D C. Simulation of tractor accidents and overturns. Transactions of the ASAE, 1976; 19(4): 602–609.

Kayacan E, Kayacan E, Ramon H, Saeys W. Nonlinear modeling and identification of an autonomous tractor–trailer system. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2014; 106: 1–10.

Kolator B, Białobrzewski I. A simulation model of 2WD tractor performance. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2011; 76(2): 231–239.

Larson D L, Smith D W, Liljedahl J B. The dynamics of three-dimensional tractor motion. Transactions of the ASAE, 1976; 19(1): 195–200.

Ahmadi I. Development of a tractor dynamic stability index calculator utilizing some tractor specifications. Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Forestry, 2013; 37(2): 203–211.

Liu B, Koc A B. SafeDriving: A mobile application for tractor rollover detection and emergency reporting. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2013; 98: 117–120.

Liu J, Ayers P D. Application of a tractor stability index for protective structure deployment. Journal of Agricultural Safety and Health, 1998; S1(1): 171–181.

Rabbani M A, Takeoka S, Mitsuoka M, Inoue E, Fukushima T, Okayasu T. Simulation for vertical dynamic loading forces on track rollers of the half-tracked tractor based on nonlinear Voigt’s model. Engineering in Agriculture, Environment and Food, 2010; 3(4): 119–126.

Vidoni R, Bietresato M, Gasparetto A, Mazzetto F. Evaluation and stability comparison of different vehicle configurations for robotic agricultural operations on side-slopes. Biosystems Engineering, 2015; 129: 197–211.

Yang J H, Sakai H, Murayama S. Side over-turning of articulated-frame skidder running along a contour line. Journal of the Japanese Forestry Society, 1991; 73(1): 1–10.

Yisa M G, Terao H, Noguchi N, Kubota M. Stability criteria for tractor-implement operation on slopes. Journal of Terramechanics, 1998; 35(1): 1–19.

Bietresato M, Carabin G, Vidoni R, Mazzetto F, Gasparetto A. A parametric approach for evaluating the stability of agricultural tractors using implements during side-slope activities. Contemporary Engineering Sciences, 2015; 8(28): 1289–1309.

Ahmadi I. Dynamics of tractor lateral overturn on slopes under the influence of position disturbances (model development). Journal of Terramechanics, 2011; 48(5): 339–346.

Chisholm C J. The effect of parameter variation on tractor overturning and impact behaviour. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1979; 24(4): 417–440.

Crolla D A, Horton D N L. Factors affecting the dynamic behaviour of higher speed agricultural vehicles. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1984; 30: 277–288.

Franceschetti B, Lenain R, Rondelli V. Comparison between a rollover tractor dynamic model and actual lateral tests. Biosystems Engineering, 2014; 127: 79–91.

Gilfillan G. Tractor behaviour during motion uphill: I. Factors affecting behaviour. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1970; 15(3): 221–235.

Gilfillan G. Tractor behaviour during motion uphill: II. Comparisons of behaviour. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1970; 15(3): 236–243.

Gravalos I, Gialamas T, Loutridis S, Moshou D, Kateris D, Xyradakis P, et al. An experimental study on the impact of the rear track width on the stability of agricultural tractors using a test bench. Journal of Terramechanics, 2011; 48(4): 319–323.

Guzzomi A L, Rondelli V. Narrow-track wheeled agricultural tractor parameter variation. Journal of Agricultural Safety and Health, 2013; 19(4): 237–260.

Lines J A, Murphy K. The radial damping of agricultural tractor tyres. Journal of Terramechanics, 1991; 28(2-3): 229–241.

Lines J A, Murphy K. The stiffness of agricultural tractor tyres. Journal of Terramechanics, 1991; 28(1): 49–64.

Lines J A, Peachey R O, Collins T S. Predicting the ride vibration of an unsuspended tractor using the dynamic characteristics of rolling tyres. Journal of Terramechanics, 1992; 29(3): 307–315.

Lines J A, Young N A. A machine for measuring the suspension characteristics of agricultural tyres. Journal of Terramechanics, 1989; 26(3-4): 201–210.

Nguyen V N, Matsuo T, Koumoto T, Inaba S. Measurement of the properties of agricultural tire for tractor dynamic analyses (Part 1) Determination of drive tire stiffness and damping from static tests. Journal of the Japanese Society of Agricultural Machinery, 2009; 71(6): 55–62.

Nguyen V N, Matsuo T, Koumoto T, Inaba S. Measurement of the properties of agricultural tire for tractor dynamic analyses (Part 2) Determination of drive tire stiffness and damping from dynamic tests. Journal of the Japanese Society of Agricultural Machinery, 2009; 71(6): 63–70.

Karkee M, Steward B L. Local and global sensitivity analysis of a tractor and single axle grain cart dynamic system model. Biosystems Engineering, 2010; 106(4): 352–366.

Li Z, Mitsuoka M, Inoue E, Okayasu T, Hirai Y. Development of stability indicators for dynamic Phase I overturn of conventional farm tractors with front axle pivot. Biosystems Engineering, 2015; 134: 55–67.

Taghavifar H, Modarres Motlagh A, Mardani A, Hassanpour A, Haji Hosseinloo A, Wei C. The induced shock and impact force as affected by the obstacle geometric factors during tire-obstacle collision dynamics. Measurement, 2016; 84: 47–55.

Takeda J, Shimada M, Kikuchi Y, Nakano M, Okada S, Hiroma T, et al. Dynamic Behaviors of Farm Tractor Passing over an Obstacle (Part 1) Improvement of Tractor Dynamic Model and Measurement of Tire Stiffness. Journal of the Japanese Society of Agricultural Machinery, 2010; 72(5): 457–463.

Takeda J, Shimada M, Kikuchi Y, Nakano M, Okada S, Hiroma T, et al. Dynamic behaviors of farm tractor passing over an obstacle (part 2) analysis on validation for improved dynamic model. Journal of the Japanese Society of Agricultural Machinery, 2010; 72(5): 464–470.

International Organization for Standardization. ISO 8608: Mechanical vibration – Road surface profiles – Reporting of measured data. 2016. Genève, Switzerland.

Li Z, Mitsuoka M, Inoue E, Okayasu T, Hirai Y, Zhu Z. Parameter sensitivity for tractor lateral stability against Phase I overturn on random road surfaces. Biosystems Engineering, 2016; 150: 10–23.

Matthews J. Ride comfort for tractor operators. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 1966; 11(1): 44–57.

Ohmiya K. Studies on roughness of meadow. Memoirs of the Research Faculty of Agriculture, Hokkaido University, 1990; 17(2): 151–209.

Torisu R, Matsuo M, Morishima S. Characteristics of the agricultural surface undulations as origins of farm tractor vibrations. Science Bulletin of the Faculty of Agriculture, Kyushu University, 1979; 34(1-2): 7–17.




Copyright (c) 2018



2023-2026 Copyright IJABE Editing and Publishing Office